Should i get kinect or playstation move

The Wii remote still gets the job done, of course, but as developers for the Xbox and Playstation start to tap the potential of the more precise motion controls, the Wii will start aging. I split graphics into two pieces: quality and gameplay. This is because as beautiful as the graphics are, if a software developer places form over function, that ruins the game. For this category, the Wii is definitely showing its age. When I look at the photo-realistic vistas in Sports Champions, it makes attempts at photo-realistic scenes in Wii games look very old.

I noticed that the graphics on the Xbox are excellent, but the Playstation just had an edge, probably due to its use of Blu-ray discs. The game we played at the Wii Party was, well, Wii Party.

Put another way, I want to hug the characters on the Wii, shake hands with the characters on the PS3, and punch the living daylights out of the characters on the Xbox. This is another place where the Wii shines and for good reason—the Wii has had a four-year head start. This will probably come as no surprise, but the Move and the Kinect both get stellar scores on this one—as long as the conditions are perfect see the next section for how things can go horribly wrong.

Here is where the Wii shines brightly and will probably continue to do so for some time. This is why the vast majority of early titles for these games are for a maximum of two players; in fact, for the Xbox games we even had to move furniture out of the way and tell people not to stand in certain places. For both the PS3 and the Xbox, players had to physically get up and stand in a confined area to play—and when they got too excited and moved out of the camera shot, their scores would suffer.

With the Wii, on the other hand, we had players sitting on sofas, sitting on the floor, and we just had to toss the controller to them when it was their turn. To me, this is the most important criteria. For this, the Wii still stands apart—for now. A lot of this is, of course, because game developers have not yet produced stellar titles for either of them. This should change over the coming year. In the meantime, hopefully Nintendo will do what it takes to keep its system on par, if not through their graphics and controller, then through accentuating the things that do give them an edge.

Bottom line, when choosing a system for yourself, see which of the components above are most relevant to your needs, and judge accordingly. A question I hear a lot for each of these systems is which configurations to buy.

It gets confusing, because most of the game companies sell different configurations, with or without motion controllers. Here are the ones to get:. It comes with the Xbox console, a handheld controller, the Kinect camera, a headset, the awful Kinect Adventures game, AC cable, AV cable, and a built-in GB hard drive you can save some money by buying the 4 GB version.

November 27th, Posted by steve in Video Game News. The camera is made up of three cameras in all; a single color camera for image recognition and two monochrome cameras placed a few inches apart to detect where you are in a three-dimensional space.

Because the system is camera-only, it needs a lot of space; Microsoft recommends 6 to 8 feet between the Kinect sensor and the user. The games: Currently, 18 Kinect games are available , way less than the available motion or move enabled games for PS3. Titles include sports mini-game compilation MotionSports, Dance Central my fave! One Kinect accommodates multiple players. Voice control is very cool and works well. You get that vibe through everything from the Kevin Butler TV commercials to the console's information design, which at times seems almost joyfully counterintuitive.

The Xbox Kinect is courting in equal parts the home theater enthusiast and the novelty seeker. Nintendo's Wii MotionPlus , at the same time, has quietly caught up by incorporating its ill-conceived external dongle into a regular-size Wiimote, but will the casual Wii audience go back and buy new control sticks?

Scott: The Move is for "hard-core gamers," according to Sony, and the button-covered design may come off as a bit intimidating for the Wii crowd. The Kinect is controller-free, and the motion-heavy gaming is perfect for fitness nuts, families, and casual players with luxurious living rooms.

Dan: Finding a place to stick a Wii sensor bar used to seem like such a hassle; if we only knew how good we had things back then.

The simplicity of that nearly passive Wii sensor bar seems positively nostalgic now; not only do the Kinect and PlayStation Move require bulky external Webcams, but both cameras are hard-wired and sure to drive the cord-conscious crazy. The PlayStation Move is actually fairly forgiving in its space requirements, at least compared with the Kinect. Maybe the tens of millions of people living in New York aren't Microsoft's target market, because we have yet to speak to an NYC apartment dweller who has not had to clamber over their sofa to set up the Kinect and you can forget about playing many of the multiplayer games.

Not to overemphasize this point, but the rigid space requirements for setting up and using the Kinect are incredibly annoying. Scott: The Wii is the most forgiving of the motion systems in terms of space, and the easiest to set up; all you need to do is attach a sensor bar, and even the Wii Fit board is self-contained. It's the best system for playing in cramped quarters, such as a dorm room or kid's bedroom.

The Move is more complicated because it also requires a camera to be installed near the TV, which won't actually be used for most PS3 games.

It requires a few feet of distance to use, but most games only register the controller's motion, not yours there are a few exceptions. The Kinect, once installed, is controller- and hassle-free, but it's also the most high-maintenance of them all to set up properly. Lighting and ambient noise need to be perfect, and your whole living room belongs to the Kinect's playspace, since your whole body is utilized in many Kinect launch games.

Dan: Microsoft's Kinect has yet to really distinguish itself in the short list of launch games , so it seems unfair to judge it too prematurely although the early examples seem to leave so-called "core" gamers out in the cold.