Manna from heaven what was it

However, some authors feel that a weakness of the theory is that it does not account for the characteristic "purity" of most of the falls.

How could a tornado coming on a marshy pond selectively lift only the frogs from the ground and leave behind all the other things plants, mud, twigs, leaves etc? Of course, the tornado would not selectively lift the frogs and leave the rest behind all would be lifted.

However, it might be expected that as the diverse mixture is carried through the air the various components would segregate out from each other according to weight, size, shape etc. This phenomenon is totally familiar to every scientist who has ever used a centrifuge. Christians and Jews are familiar with the Old Testament account of manna falling from the sky to sustain the Israelites during the exodus from Egypt.

Several scientific investigations have been carried out in order to construct a natural explanation for the manna. Investigation of the phenomenon is facilitated by the fact that falls of manna continue to occur occasionally in the Middle East.

Manna means the fall of any whitish substance having some nutritional value. Apparently manna can have several sources. In a heavy fall occurred in Turkey, where it was collected and used to make bread which is reported to have been of good quality. The manna consisted of small spheres which, upon examination by botanists, were found to be composed of lichen.

The lichen is found mainly on arid mountains in eastern Europe and in Asia. It is thought to have been transported to Turkey by a tornado. Falls of manna can also have other sources. A detailed investigation carried out by the Hebrew University of Jerusalem in the Sinai peninsula discovered that the appearance of manna is a well known phenomenon in the region and is caused by excretions of insects that live on desert shrubs.

The dry desert atmosphere causes the fluid excretions to crystallise and the resulting white grains fall to the ground. I have only found a few references to unusual falls in Ireland. Charles Fort, an American journalist, has collected and published many accounts of strange objects falling from the sky. One very intriguing Irish fall reported by Fort occurred in Munster and Leinster in The material that fell was described as "soft, clammy and of dark yellow colour".

It fell in lumps "as big as the ends of one's, fingers" and was called "butter" by the country people. It had a strong, bad smell. The other two Irish falls that I have seen mentioned are more prosaic. One was of hay recorded in at Monkstown, Co Dublin. The other was a peculiar fall of berries that fell in the city of Dublin in The manna stopped.

This plant may be similar in texture and named after manna because it reminds the Jews of the manna that they ate. But they ate bread from heaven, not insect byproduct. Agree with Davida on that completely. You have to also think about the number of people that were there. If that was the case, it would have been documented. How did it follow them all the way to Canaan and then stop once they reached there and the 40 years were up?

Actually, scholars have misunderstood the numbers specified in Exodus. There could not have been more than about , to , Israelites, which, if interpreted and translated correctly is the number that is provided in the Biblical text.

Thank you Victor! I try and correct this error whenever I speak about Exodus. Interesting topic though. Agree with top. If you read about manna this manna outside of this article you would find that it does actually fall to the ground.

The insect manna falls to the ground where it is collected still today. Also it matches up with the Exodus story because it also goes away mid day. As soon as the sun hits it, it evaporates. So this matches perfectly the Exodus story. God created all, including all biological processes that create manna today.

The miracle would have been A God all knowing sending them through the portions of the desert that have manna not all do , B miraculously ensuring enough insects each Friday to produce enough manna for two days, C providing a way for the manna not to evaporate on Sabbath. It can be both. Jesus said in John 6. The Lord is making the point, just as manna came from heaven… so did I. As a matter of fact, he said, I am the true manna from heaven. Yes, there were two miracles associated with Manna.

The first was, as you indicated, the fact that the Manna collected on Friday morning was still good on Saturday. The other miracle was the sheer amount, an impossible amount, of Manna, not the existence of Manna itself. God took an available foodstuff and multiplied it 1, fold as Jesus did twice with bread and fish. Aletha jones pmmanna was food for the Israelites and one of the items in the ark of the covenant and also another item was Aaron rod and also the tablet.

The book of Numbers says it was as a coriander seed but the color of bdellium so it really was the same seed that The Lord commanded Moses and Aaron to lay up an Omer full in the Ark of the Holy covenant for their generations may see what he fed them with. Could this Manna be the fruit of the Tree of Life? I would really be interested in what seed it actually is. That miracles exist with scientific explanations does not, for me, make them any less miraculous!

Like so many other natural, explainable things — including the amazing, impossible example of LIFE ITSELF, and the diversity of living things on this planet alone — that the secretions of insects drinking the sap of certain plants, st certain times, could render a sweet, nourishing product is miracle enough for me. God is the ultimate Scientist, Botanist, Engineer, Zoologist and anything else. His works and miracles are in plain sight every day, even amongst the most seemingly common, mundane things.

Including our beating hearts and the breath we breath. Your email address will not be published. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. January 19, By Vered Guttman. Tags: Food , Talk of the Table , Torah. Facebook Twitter Pinterest linkedin Telegram.

November 2, By Sarah Breger 1 comment. Summer Issue , Talk of the Table. Food , Spring issue , Talk of the Table. May 13, By Nadine Epstein 1 comment. April 5, By Diane M. Bolz 1 comment. October 2, By Dan Freedman 0 comments. August 31, By Lilly Gelman 0 comments. April 13, By Moment 0 comments. April 7, By Joan Nathan 0 comments. Jewish World , Latest , Lighter fare , Zoominars.

May 7, By Moment 2 comments. Because of this passage, manna was often interpreted by rabbis as the food of the age to come, rather than some temporary snack to keep the Israelites tided over during their years in the wilderness.

In such an interpretation, manna is of even greater significance. In short, there are quite a few unknowns surrounding manna. Nevertheless, the Bible does provide us with some clues as to the identity of manna.

It looked like white coriander seeds, and tasted like wafers with honey: sweet, in other words. So, was manna a lichen, or at least the globules produced by this particular lichen? A more likely candidate which fits all of the details of the Exodus account is actually insect-related, as improbable as that sounds.

Exodus is not the only book of the Bible which provides an account of manna from heaven. The Book of Numbers, too, adds some further details:. Bdellium is a kind of gum resin which is not dissimilar to myrrh, which formed one of the three gifts the Magi brought to Jesus in the New Testament.