Why is kirby puckett in the hall of fame

However, these 10 are some of the worst selections ever made. Bresnahan was basically a journeyman catcher who played for six different teams over 17 seasons. He is best known for introducing shin guards to the catcher uniform. He also experimented with thigh pads and a batting helmet, despite ridicule from other players. This eventually led to the widespread implementation of such safety gear in the early 20th century.

However, the last time I checked, having a sense of style and fondness for protective gear are not criteria for a Hall of Fame selection.

Bresnahan collected only RBI while batting. He later managed for five years and wound up with a losing record of After developing a sore arm in his 20s, Faber began using the spitball in to advance his baseball career. Faber is considered the best spitballer of all time, which was legal to throw at the time.

But is tossing the best spitball a reason for induction? Faber's career 3. He did play on several winning teams, but was sometimes so bad that he was demoted to the bullpen a number of times throughout his career. How does a player with a. Because he hit what was considered at the time to be the greatest home run in World Series history. The Game 7 walk-off shot gave the Pirates their first World Championship in 35 years.

While Mazeroski did collect eight Gold Gloves and was respected for his great defense, he was not great offensively. Haines was a totally mediocre pitcher for his time, with a record and a 3.

In 19 seasons, Haines collected only strikeouts, with a 1. If you enjoy sabermetrics, Haines recorded an average WAR number of wins contributed in a season of only 1. Business Study: Mpls. Paul minimum wage increases led to loss of restaurant jobs November Opinion Exchange Minnesota's long wrong turn on natural resources November Nation Olympic gold medalist Suni Lee says she was pepper sprayed in racist attack in L. November Taste 10 great cinnamon and caramel rolls from Twin Cities area bakeries November More From Star Tribune.

More From RandBall. Twins December 2, Why would they just let him go? Here are some answers based on how baseball has changed. Sports November 25, Sports November 24, A double pass from your own end zone when leading by 36 in the closing seconds?

Sure, why not. Wolves November 23, Anthony Edwards is the most important new player in the long run and Ricky Rubio is the most interesting acquisition.

For the coming season, though, you need to know about Ed Davis. The Hall of Fame is about greatness , not goodness for an extended period of time.

Barely a. A good number of his 24 seasons were poor and he was never the best pitcher in the league. The first black player in the American League was elected primarily for that distinction. While Larry Doby had a solid year career as the center fielder for the Cleveland Indians, slugging career home runs and twice leading the league in that category, his overall statistics and career longevity fall short of Hall of Fame induction.

But he also lost and gave up 96 home runs in just two seasons. When he retired he was third all time in strikeouts. Armed with a devastating curveball Blyleven hung on for a long time, but was barely a. He took home an MVP award when there were clearly more deserving players, not only in the league, but on his own team in But a. With power and speed, Andre Dawson combined for home runs and stolen bases but knee issues slowed down his production in later years. A move to the AL and becoming a DH would have padded his statistics, but with a poor OBP and less-than stellar overall career totals, Dawson misses the cut.

His selection was all about timing—appearing on the ballot as the strongest candidate in a weak class. The hero of the World Series will always be remembered as the only player to hit a walk-off home run in Game 7 of the World Series. But Bill Mazeroski did little else in his career. He was very average offensively for the majority of his career, batting.

For one moment in time he was the best, but that moment is long past and does not make a career. Enjoy our content?